
Between the rails – why investor protection is critical
Guard rails… it’s become a popular term. Somewhat self explanatory, the term means to keep something within certain constraints generally protecting the user or society in general.
We have heard the term used in the context of AI. Indeed it was used throughout the legislative process of the EU AI Act to describe the regulatory boundaries and controls established to ensure the safe and ethical development and deployment of Artificial Intelligence. The term appeared in both public discourse and official commentary as early as 2021, when the Act was first proposed. It was used by lawmakers, regulators, and commentators to communicate the intent of the legislation to “draw up guardrails for Artificial Intelligence” that protect health, safety, and fundamental rights.
In the context of our own industry, Regulation and the Central Bank’s Consumer Protection mandate is designed to provide guard rails to protect the consumer not just from improper conduct and dodgy dealings but also to provide a framework within which they are protected from their own fallibility. Whilst striking the right balance and ensuring rules are applied proportionately, regulation has been a boon to consumers in respect of protecting against a broad array of issues from catastrophic failures to poor design to fraud and beyond. The benefit of having a reasonable level of constraint is evidenced by the near total absence of catastrophic failure in the insured world versus some of the extreme calamity that has been experienced in the unregulated space.
Consumers benefit from the protections baked into packaged retail investors products such as insured investment bonds such as diversification, professional investment management, appropriate governance, having a strong regulated counterparty and clarity in respect of taxation. These products have no trading incentive and limit typical behavioural biases that invariably cost consumers in the long run. Buying a multi asset fund through an insured investment bond is hardly sexy but it is very unlikely to go wrong.
Let’s contrast this to the self-serve world of ETF’s which are currently the darling of certain media commentators and policy makers alike. Unlike an insured investment bond, ETF’s, whilst regulated, offer few of the protections of the former. Matters such as where the fund is domiciled, what currency it is denominated in, whether it distributes or accumulates and the cost all have a significant impact on the individual investments suitability. Individual ETF’s may be highly diversified or they may be highly concentrated and hence may or may not deliver the same diversification benefits of a typical insurance company multi-asset fund. They also may or may not hold the underlying assets that you wish to invest in as some will operate on a synthetic basis. You also need a way of trading these products which adds a further layer of cost. Assets need to be held which requires consideration as to the counterparty who is ultimately responsible for your money. Finally there is the small matter of taxation, unlike insured investment bonds where tax is deducted at source, it is the individual’s responsibility to return taxes and perhaps also deal with withholding tax, with gains and losses on each line item in a given period given correct tax treatment. A tax return must also be made with prudence dictating a suitably knowledgeable accountant be employed to file which again loads in a layer of cost. We could go on but safe to say the world of ETF’s is not simple, nor should it be considered so.
Whilst ETF’s are an excellent tool and relevant to larger individual investors, they generally come into their own in portfolios with a value of several hundred thousand euros. Costs are invariably higher for regular retail investors. Costs aside, crucially ETF’s do not offer the same essential guard rails as those which apply to insured investment bonds. There is a lot to be said for a single packaged product which wraps all the complexity of market based investing into a single product that being the life insurance investment bond.
The European imperative to mobilise household savings is laudable and has rightly been embraced by Irish policy makers. Reducing exit tax from 41% to 33% in line with other capital taxes would be most welcome and would no doubt go a long way to displacing capital to productive purposes. However, we caution policy makers in respect of their priorities. Retail money is best encouraged into properly constructed and regulated retail products with all the good designs and safety backstops that come with them. Focus should be on the life insurance investment bonds market with ETFs also having relevance but more so to larger, more sophisticated individuals and investment professionals. From the State’s perspective, tax compliance must also be considered. Tax on life insurance investment bonds is collected at source ensuring 100% compliance. Given the more complex nature of the taxation of ETF’s, in a large fragment market, it is unlikely that compliance approaching this level could be achieved.
Our advice, keep it between the rails and let policy direct retail investors money to where it belongs, in packaged retail investment products.







